- The short answer
- The three IRC 6038 penalties
- Who assessed it: read the transcript first
- Reasonable cause under the regulation
- What the IRM says is not reasonable cause
- First Time Abate and Form 5471
- Systemic penalties on late Forms 1120 and 1065
- Farhy: can the IRS assess the penalty at all
- How to request abatement
- If the request is denied: Appeals
- Questions practitioners ask
The short answer
The Form 5471 penalty is a flat amount under IRC 6038(b). It is assessed without a notice of deficiency, so the first notice the client sees is usually a CP15 or CP215 penalty charge. The routes to relief are:
Sources: IRM 20.1.9.3.5IRM 20.1.9.3.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; IRM 21.8.2.20.2IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(3)Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2Treasury regulations, Cornell LII.
This page is about Form 5471. The other international forms, and the notice letters for each, are covered in international information return penalties.
The three IRC 6038 penalties
| Penalty | Authority | Amount | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial penalty | IRC 6038(b)(1)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII; Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(1)(i)Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2Treasury regulations, Cornell LII | $10,000 for each annual accounting period of each foreign corporation | One per form per year |
| Continuation penalty | IRC 6038(b)(2)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII; Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(1)(ii)Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2Treasury regulations, Cornell LII | $10,000 for each 30-day period, or part of one, that the failure continues more than 90 days after the IRS mails notice | $50,000 for each failure |
| Foreign tax credit reduction | IRC 6038(c)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII; Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(2)Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2Treasury regulations, Cornell LII | Foreign taxes available for credit reduced by 10%, plus 5% for each 3-month period the failure continues after a 90-day notice | Greater of $10,000 or the foreign corporation’s income for the period; reduced by the dollar penalty |
The statute states the first penalty in one sentence: the person “shall pay a penalty of $10,000 for each annual accounting period with respect to which such failure exists”. The continuation penalty is capped: “The increase in any penalty under this paragraph shall not exceed $50,000.” IRM 20.1.9.3.4IRM 20.1.9.3.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov adds the two together: “The maximum total failure to file penalty under IRC 6038(b)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII is $60,000 per Form 5471 or Form 8865 required to be filed per year”.
The penalty is per form. A shareholder with three controlled foreign corporations and two late years has six failures. An incomplete form counts: the IRM describes the initial penalty as applying to a failure to timely file complete and accurate information. The foreign tax credit reduction under IRC 6038(c)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII is different in kind. IRM 8.11.5.2IRM 8.11.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov lists it among the international penalties that are subject to deficiency procedures, so it is disputed with the related income tax, not on the civil penalty module.
The 90-day notice has no give in it. “There is no provision in the IRC or Treas. Regs. for an extension of the 90-day period described in the notice letter.” Calendar it to the day.
Who assessed it: read the transcript first
Where the request goes, and which relief is open, depends on who assessed the penalty. The civil penalty module (MFT 13 for a business, MFT 55 for an individual) shows it.
| What the transcript shows | How it was assessed | Who considers abatement | Relief available |
|---|---|---|---|
| TC 240, PRN 599, Document Code 54, in multiples of $10,000 | Systemically, on a Form 5471 attached to a late Form 1120 series return | The BMF International units at the Ogden and Cincinnati Accounts Management centers | Reasonable cause, or relief following the related return, including First Time Abate |
| TC 240, PRN 712, Document Code 54 | Systemically, on a Form 5471 attached to a late Form 1065 | The same campus units | Same |
| PRN 623, Document Code 47 (or 54) | By Examination, on Form 8278 | The Examination unit that assessed it | Reasonable cause |
| PRN 619 | Continuation penalty, by Examination | The Examination unit that assessed it | No reasonable cause exception under the IRM |
The IRM is emphatic about the split. IRM 21.8.2.20.2IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: “Accounts Management WILL NOT consider penalty abatement requests on Examination assessed penalties.” And IRM 20.1.9.2IRM 20.1.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: “Reasonable cause determinations can only be made by the unit that asserted the penalty”. A request sent to the wrong place is forwarded, not worked. Systemic assessment exists only on business accounts. IRM 8.11.5.5IRM 8.11.5.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov notes that individual (IMF) accounts do not have automated Form 5471 assessments.
Reasonable cause under the regulation
IRC 6038IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII has no reasonable cause clause in the usual form. Instead, IRC 6038(c)(4)(B)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII moves the deadline: for both the dollar penalty and the credit reduction, the time for furnishing the information, and the start of the 90-day period, “shall be treated as being not earlier than the last day on which (as shown to the satisfaction of the Secretary) reasonable cause existed for failure to furnish such information”. A form filed while reasonable cause still existed is treated as on time.
Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(3) sets the procedure. The person required to report “must make an affirmative showing of all facts alleged as reasonable cause for such failure in a written statement”, and the statement must contain a declaration that it is made under the penalties of perjury. It is filed with the IRS office where the return is required to be filed, which decides whether there was reasonable cause and for how long. The same paragraph has a second ground that is easy to miss, for a form that was filed but incomplete: if the person “has substantially complied with this section, then the omission or error shall not constitute a failure under this section”.
IRM 8.11.5.5.2IRM 8.11.5.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov confirms that reasonable cause relief is available for IRC 6038IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalties and points to the general standard in IRM 20.1.1.3.2IRM 20.1.1.3.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov and Treas. Reg. 301.6651-1(c)Treas. Reg. 301.6651-1Treasury regulations, Cornell LII: ordinary business care and prudence. See reasonable cause for how the IRS weighs the facts, and what the courts accept. A statement that works for a Form 5471 penalty covers:
- Each foreign corporation and each year, since each penalty stands on its own.
- Why the form was not filed on time, as dated facts: who was responsible, what they knew, what advice was sought and from whom.
- When the failure was discovered and what was done, with the filing dates. Reasonable cause has to last until the form is filed.
- That every other required international return is now filed. The IRM recommends that reasonable cause not be considered for any year until all delinquent returns are in (IRM 20.1.9.3.5)IRM 20.1.9.3.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- The declaration under penalties of perjury, signed by the taxpayer.
The reasonable cause letter template can be adapted; add the perjury declaration and the entity-by-entity facts.
What the IRM says is not reasonable cause
IRM 20.1.9.2IRM 20.1.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov (part of IRM 20.1.9) tells examiners to keep in mind that these penalties generally fall on people with business or investment activity abroad, and that ordinary care requires researching the filing obligations of all jurisdictions. It then lists what is not enough on its own. Reasonable cause should not be granted merely because a foreign country would penalize disclosure, because a foreign trustee refuses to provide information, or because of reliance on someone else: “The taxpayer relied on another person to file returns.” The IRM goes on to say it is the taxpayer’s responsibility to ensure that all returns are filed timely and accurately.
Three more statements from the same section shape a request:
- Relief on the tax return does not carry over by itself. “The fact that reasonable cause relief was granted to the related income tax return does not automatically provide relief for the failure to timely file the information returns.” (The systemic penalties below are the exception, by a specific IRM rule.)
- Repeated failures count against the older years. The IRM says a repeated failure to file does not support a claim of normal business care for the older, late-filed years.
- A denial must be in writing. Examiners must issue a determination letter if reasonable cause was requested and denied.
The IRM line on reliance is about handing the filing to someone else. For how the IRS and the courts treat reliance on an adviser’s advice, see reasonable cause: what the courts accept.
First Time Abate and Form 5471
First Time Abate is an administrative waiver for the failure-to-file, failure-to-pay and failure-to-deposit penalties. On its own terms it does not reach Form 5471. IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1IRM 20.1.1.3.3.2.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov excludes returns with an event-based filing requirement and information reporting that depends on another filing, and IRM 20.1.9.3.5IRM 20.1.9.3.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov says: “The first time abatement (FTA) penalty relief provisions do not apply to event-based filing requirements such as with Form 5471”.
The same paragraph then makes one exception, for the systemic penalty only (PRN 599 or 712). If the failure-to-file penalty on the related Form 1120 or Form 1065 is abated under First Time Abate, or the return would have qualified but no failure-to-file penalty was assessed because no tax was due or it was fully paid, the Form 5471 penalty may be abated on the same basis, if two more conditions are met:
- The taxpayer had no similar penalties (PRN 599, 623 or 712) in the three prior periods.
- The related Form 1120 or Form 1065 was not filed late in the three prior periods.
IRM 8.11.5.2IRM 8.11.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov gives Appeals the same rule: the waiver is generally not applicable to international penalties, with this exception for systemically assessed Form 5471 and Form 5472 penalties. A penalty assessed by an examiner (PRN 623) gets no First Time Abate under the IRM. For those, reasonable cause is the route.
First Time Abate has to be earned on the related return, not on the Form 5471. Check the Form 1120 or Form 1065 history for the three prior periods before asking; the First Time Abate eligibility checker walks through the general criteria.
Systemic penalties on late Forms 1120 and 1065
Since 2009 the IRS has assessed the initial penalty by computer when a Form 5471 is attached to a late Form 1120 series return, and since 2014 when it is attached to a late Form 1065: $10,000 for each attached Form 5471, with a CP215 notice (IRM 21.8.2.20.2)IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. No examiner looks at the case first. Because the Form 5471 is due with the income tax return, including extensions, a return that is late by a day makes every attached Form 5471 late.
The campus decides these penalties alongside the late-filing penalty on the return:
| Situation on the related Form 1120 or Form 1065 | Result for the Form 5471 penalty | Source |
|---|---|---|
| An extension was filed but posted after the return | The penalty is reversed. Since January 1, 2016 the system does this itself when the extension posts | IRM 21.8.2.20.2IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; IRM 20.1.9.3.5IRM 20.1.9.3.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Late-filing penalty abated for reasonable cause (a reason code other than First Time Abate), and no similar Form 5471 penalties in the three prior periods | May be abated with the same reason code | IRM 20.1.9.3.5(3)IRM 20.1.9.3.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| Late-filing penalty abated under First Time Abate, or not assessed because no tax was due, and the two history conditions are met | May be abated under First Time Abate | IRM 20.1.9.3.5(3)IRM 20.1.9.3.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov; IRM 21.8.2.20.2IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
| None of the above | Reasonable cause must be shown for the Form 5471 itself, in writing | IRM 20.1.9.3.5(3)IRM 20.1.9.3.5(3)Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov |
Three practical points. The campus will not decide until the related return question is settled and all required returns have posted. Its starting position is to follow the return: “The International Department will generally abate/deny the Form 5471 initial penalty consistent with the determination made on the "related Form 1120 or Form 1065."” So ask for both at once, in one letter. And a reasonable cause abatement of the Form 5471 penalty needs a manager’s approval at the campus, which is a reason to make the statement complete the first time. For the late-filing penalty on the return itself, see the failure-to-file penalty and late partnership return penalty pages.
Two special rules appear in the form instructions and the IRM. The Instructions for Form 5471 (Rev. December 2025) say certain penalties under IRC 6038IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII may be waived for certain filers under Rev. Proc. 2019-40. And Notice 2022-36 removed systemic Form 5471 penalties for 2019 and 2020 tax years on returns filed by September 30, 2022, without a request (IRM 21.8.2.20.2)IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Farhy: can the IRS assess the penalty at all
IRC 6038(b)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII says the person “shall pay” the penalty but does not say it is assessed and collected like a tax. In Farhy v. Commissioner, 160 T.C. No. 6 (Apr. 3, 2023), a collection due process case over a levy for Form 5471 penalties, the Tax Court held that the IRS lacks statutory authority to assess IRC 6038(b)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalties and could not collect them by levy. The court pointed to 28 USC 2461(a), under which a penalty with no stated mode of recovery may be recovered in a civil action.
The D.C. Circuit reversed on May 3, 2024 (No. 23-1179), holding that “the text, structure, and function of section 6038 demonstrate that Congress authorized assessment of penalties imposed under subsection (b)”.
The Tax Court did not change its view for cases that go to other circuits. In Mukhi v. Commissioner, 163 T.C. No. 8 (Nov. 18, 2024), on the IRS’s motion to reconsider after the reversal, it wrote: “An appeal from this decision would lie in the Eighth Circuit, and therefore, we are not bound by Golsen, 54 T.C. at 757, to follow the decision of the D.C. Circuit.” It then reached the same result as before: “Respondent assessed the section 6038(b)(1) penalties without the statutory authority to do so.”
Where that leaves a practitioner:
- The IRS still assesses. The IRM sections cited on this page, including the September 2025 Appeals revision, treat IRC 6038(b)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalties as assessed penalties.
- The circuit decides. In a case appealable to the D.C. Circuit the penalty is assessable. In the Tax Court elsewhere, Farhy and Mukhi are that court’s precedent unless the circuit of appeal has ruled otherwise. Check for a decision from the client’s circuit before relying on the argument; the decisions on this page run through November 2024.
- It is a collection defense, not abatement. Both cases arose in collection due process hearings on a levy notice. The taxpayer in Farhy did not dispute that the penalty was owed. The argument is about administrative collection. It does not cancel the liability, which the Tax Court in Farhy said may be recovered in a civil action.
- It is narrow. The holdings concern IRC 6038(b)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. Reasonable cause under the regulation remains the way to remove the penalty on the merits.
How to request abatement
- Get the transcript for the civil penalty module and identify the penalty reference number and document code. They tell you who assessed it. See reading an account transcript.
- Make the client current. File every late Form 5471 and any other late international return, complete and accurate. IRM 20.1.9.2.4IRM 20.1.9.2.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov has the examiner check full compliance for all open years before reconsidering a penalty.
- For a systemic penalty, deal with the related return. Request abatement of the Form 1120 or Form 1065 late-filing penalty and the Form 5471 penalty together, and state the First Time Abate history if it applies.
- Write the reasonable cause statement with the facts for each entity and year, signed by the taxpayer under penalties of perjury (Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(3)(ii); IRM 20.1.9.2)Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2Treasury regulations, Cornell LIIIRM 20.1.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
- Send it to the unit that assessed. For a systemic penalty the IRM gives the address for written requests: Internal Revenue Service, 1973 Rulon White Blvd., Mail Stop 6552, Ogden, Utah 84404 (IRM 21.8.2.20.2)IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. For an Examination penalty, send it to the examiner or group that assessed it. A Form 843 claim is routed the same way: IRM 21.8.2.20.1IRM 21.8.2.20.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov has the campus forward Form 843 claims on Examination penalties to the area that assessed them.
- Watch the collection notices while it is pending. The request does not stop them. Keep the client’s collection due process deadlines.
- If denied, appeal within the time stated in the denial letter.
If the penalty has been paid, timing matters. IRM 8.11.5.4.1IRM 8.11.5.4.1Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov says a penalty abatement request is not an informal claim for refund, and that a paid penalty is not abated where the refund period under IRC 6511IRC 6511Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII has run. Where the client has paid, make the request a refund claim as well and file it within that period.
If the request is denied: Appeals
A denied request can be taken to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals without paying the penalty. IRM 8.11.5.2IRM 8.11.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: “Appeals currently provides a prepayment, post assessment appeal process for assessed international penalties.” The penalty must already be assessed; Appeals returns a case sent before assessment. The campus denial of a systemic penalty request comes with Letter 854C, which gives the appeal rights.
Appeals considers penalty relief in a set order: correction of an IRS error, statutory exceptions, administrative waivers, reasonable cause, and then hazards of litigation. The last is where an unsettled legal question counts. IRM 8.11.5.4IRM 8.11.5.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov: “Appeals may recommend abatement of the penalty based on hazards of litigation.” The same section says Appeals will not trade a penalty concession for a concession on another issue. For how to write the protest, see appealing a penalty abatement denial. Before the penalty reaches Appeals, check that the examiner’s supervisor approved it in writing where IRC 6751(b) requires it.
Questions practitioners ask
Can a Form 5471 penalty be abated?
Yes. Reasonable cause relief is available for IRC 6038IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalties (IRM 8.11.5.5.2)IRM 8.11.5.5.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov. The taxpayer must show the facts in a written statement made under penalties of perjury (Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2(k)(3))Treas. Reg. 1.6038-2Treasury regulations, Cornell LII. A systemic penalty on a late Form 1120 or Form 1065 can also be abated in line with the late-filing penalty on that return.
Does First Time Abate apply to Form 5471 penalties?
Not directly. IRM 20.1.9.3.5IRM 20.1.9.3.5Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov says the waiver does not apply to event-based filings such as Form 5471. The exception is a systemically assessed penalty (PRN 599 or 712): if the related Form 1120 or Form 1065 qualifies for First Time Abate and the taxpayer had no similar penalties and no late related returns in the three prior periods, the Form 5471 penalty may be abated too.
How much is the penalty for a late Form 5471?
$10,000 for each foreign corporation for each annual accounting period (IRC 6038(b)(1))IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII. If the form is still not filed 90 days after the IRS mails a notice, another $10,000 applies for each 30-day period, up to $50,000 more, for a maximum of $60,000 per form per year (IRM 20.1.9.3.4)IRM 20.1.9.3.4Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov.
Where do I send a Form 5471 penalty abatement request?
To the unit that assessed the penalty. For a penalty assessed by computer on a late Form 1120 or Form 1065, IRM 21.8.2.20.2IRM 21.8.2.20.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov gives Internal Revenue Service, 1973 Rulon White Blvd., Mail Stop 6552, Ogden, Utah 84404. A penalty assessed by an examiner goes back to Examination.
Is reliance on a tax preparer reasonable cause for a late Form 5471?
Not if the reliance was only on the preparer to file. IRM 20.1.9.2IRM 20.1.9.2Internal Revenue Manual, irs.gov says reasonable cause should not be granted merely because the taxpayer relied on another person to file returns. The request has to show ordinary business care and prudence on the facts.
Did Farhy eliminate Form 5471 penalties?
No. The Tax Court held in 2023 that the IRS cannot assess the IRC 6038(b)IRC 6038Internal Revenue Code, Cornell LII penalty, the D.C. Circuit reversed in 2024, and the Tax Court kept its position in Mukhi for a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit. The dispute is about how the penalty is collected, and the answer depends on the circuit.